Week 5- Tolbert could get a touchdown, or he could put up zero points for your team. Keep him on your bench in Week 5.
By now everyone knows what to expect out of Mike Tolbert, every week he will be a candidate to score a TD or two for the Panthers as he will be the goal line back. His fantasy value is minimal, however, as the Panthers will already feature DeAngelo Williams and Jonathan Stewart as their regular running backs. View Tolbert as more of a backup RB at this point that should only be a stopgap option for your fantasy team when you have injuries.