Comparing deep league mock drafts – 14 team draft results and ranks from fantasy football calculator and yahoo

Advertisement
14

14 (Photo credit: xiaming)

Thought it would be fun to do a side by side comparison of two deep league mock drafts that I recently completed.  On the left side we have the results from fantasy football calculator (popular mock draft site) and on the right are the results from Yahoo.  Both mock drafts were completed for the same position requirements – 1 QB, 2 RB, 3 WR, TE, DEF, K, and 6 bench spots for a total of 15 players.

If you are an avid fantasy football player, chances are the rankings seem pretty set in stone to you (especially for the first 2-3 rounds) but as you will see with this comparison, the rankings are drastically different depending on the site that you are using.  Both mocks were completed on June 11th, with all 14 fantasy owners in attendance, and they can’t even agree on the basic order for the first round!

The one trend that you will notice, as expected, is that the running backs went early and often

Deep league mock draft comparison – 14 teams

FantasyFootballCalculator.com                                                             Yahoo.com

RankPlayerTeamPOSRankPlayerTeamPOS
1Arian FosterHOURB1Adrian PetersonMINRB
2Adrian PetersonMINRB2Arian FosterHOURB
3Marshawn LynchSEARB3Doug MartinTBRB
4Jamaal CharlesKCRB4LeSean McCoyPHIRB
5Doug MartinTBRB5C.J. SpillerBUFRB
6Calvin JohnsonDETWR6Jamaal CharlesKCRB
7C.J. SpillerBUFRB7Calvin JohnsonDETWR
8Ray RiceBALRB8Ray RiceBALRB
9LeSean McCoyPHIRB9Marshawn LynchSEARB
10Alfred MorrisWASRB10Trent RichardsonCLERB
11Trent RichardsonCLERB11Alfred MorrisWASRB
12Dez BryantDALWR12Maurice Jones-DrewJACRB
13Matt ForteCHIRB13Steven JacksonATLRB
14A.J. GreenCINWR14Dez BryantDALWR
15Steven JacksonATLRB15Darren SprolesNORB
16Chris JohnsonTENRB16Drew BreesNOQB
17Maurice Jones-DrewJACRB17A.J. GreenCINWR
18Stevan RidleyNERB18Matt ForteCHIRB
19Frank GoreSFRB19Brandon MarshallCHIWR
20David WilsonNYGRB20Julio JonesATLWR
21Brandon MarshallCHIWR21Peyton ManningDENQB
22DeMarco MurrayDALRB22Aaron RodgersGBQB
23Julio JonesATLWR23Jimmy GrahamNOTE
24Demaryius ThomasDENWR24Larry FitzgeraldARIWR
25Darren McFaddenOAKRB25Chris JohnsonTENRB
26Jimmy GrahamNOTE26Demaryius ThomasDENWR
27Aaron RodgersGBQB27Stevan RidleyNERB
28Reggie BushDETRB28Cam NewtonCARQB
29Drew BreesNOQB29Victor CruzNYGWR
30Percy HarvinSEAWR30Randall CobbGBWR
31Roddy WhiteATLWR31Roddy WhiteATLWR
32Montee BallDENRB32Percy HarvinSEAWR
33Larry FitzgeraldARIWR33Tom BradyNEQB
34Darren SprolesNORB34Andre JohnsonHOUWR
35Randall CobbGBWR35Frank GoreSFRB
36Andre JohnsonHOUWR36Matt RyanATLQB
37Lamar MillerMIARB37Vincent JacksonTBWR
38Le’Veon BellPITRB38Darren McFaddenOAKRB
39Peyton ManningDENQB39Marques ColstonNOWR
40Chris IvoryNYJRB40Matthew StaffordDETQB
41Marques ColstonNOWR41Lamar MillerMIARB
42Tom BradyNEQB42Reggie WayneINDWR
43Ryan MathewsSDRB43DeMarco MurrayDALRB
44Dwayne BoweKCWR44Antonio BrownPITWR
45Cam NewtonCARQB45Reggie BushDETRB
46Vincent JacksonTBWR46Jordy NelsonGBWR
47Danny AmendolaNEWR47Russell WilsonSEAQB
48Jason WittenDALTE48Le’Veon BellPITRB
49Jordy NelsonGBWR49Wes WelkerDENWR
50Colin KaepernickSFQB50David WilsonNYGRB
51Victor CruzNYGWR51Colin KaepernickSFQB
52Reggie WayneINDWR52Dwayne BoweKCWR
53Rob GronkowskiNETE53Ryan MathewsSDRB
54BenJarvus Green-EllisCINRB54Hakeem NicksNYGWR
55Wes WelkerDENWR55Danny AmendolaNEWR
56Hakeem NicksNYGWR56Aaron HernandezNETE
57Mike WallaceMIAWR57Torrey SmithBALWR
58Aaron HernandezNETE58Eric DeckerDENWR
59Vernon DavisSFTE59Montee BallDENRB
60Matt RyanATLQB60Mike WallaceMIAWR
61Eddie LacyGBRB61Rob GronkowskiNETE
62Vick BallardINDRB62Steve SmithCARWR
63Torrey SmithBALWR63James JonesGBWR
64Rashard MendenhallARIRB64Anquan BoldinSFWR
65Matthew StaffordDETQB65Robert Griffin IIIWASQB
66Tavon AustinSTLWR66Tony GonzalezATLTE
67Antonio BrownPITWR67Andrew LuckINDQB
68Pierre GarconWASWR68Pierre GarconWASWR
69Robert Griffin IIIWASQB69Lance MooreNOWR
70Tony GonzalezATLTE70Steve JohnsonBUFWR
71Danario AlexanderSDWR71Jason WittenDALTE
72Eric DeckerDENWR72Justin BlackmonJACWR
73Steve SmithCARWR7349ersSFDEF/ST
74Mark IngramNORB74Danario AlexanderSDWR
75Russell WilsonSEAQB75DeSean JacksonPHIWR
76Greg JenningsMINWR76Dennis PittaBALTE
77Giovani BernardCINRB77Vernon DavisSFTE
78Andrew LuckINDQB78Greg JenningsMINWR
79Tony RomoDALQB79Jeremy MaclinPHIWR
80Andre BrownNYGRB80Vick BallardINDRB
81James JonesGBWR81Tony RomoDALQB
82Cecil ShortsJACWR82Kyle RudolphMINTE
83Fred JacksonBUFRB83Eli ManningNYGQB
84Daryl RichardsonSTLRB84Chris IvoryNYJRB
85Miles AustinDALWR85Cecil ShortsJACWR
86Anquan BoldinSFWR86Owen DanielsHOUTE
87Eli ManningNYGQB87Ben RoethlisbergerPITQB
88T.Y. HiltonINDWR88Josh GordonCLEWR
89Antonio GatesSDTE89Miles AustinDALWR
90Johnathan FranklinGBRB90Rashard MendenhallARIRB
91Kyle RudolphMINTE91Greg OlsenCARTE
92Dennis PittaBALTE92BenJarvus Green-EllisCINRB
93Steve JohnsonBUFWR93T.Y. HiltonINDWR
94Lance MooreNOWR94Tavon AustinSTLWR
95Jeremy MaclinPHIWR95Eddie LacyGBRB
96Kenny BrittTENWR96Mike WilliamsTBWR
97Zac StacySTLRB97Martellus BennettCHITE
98Ahmad BradshawINDRB98Michael VickPHIQB
99DeAndre HopkinsHOUWR99Daryl RichardsonSTLRB
100Jonathan StewartCARRB100Stephen GostkowskiNEK
101DeSean JacksonPHIWR101Antonio GatesSDTE
102Jared CookSTLTE102Ahmad BradshawINDRB
103SeahawksSEADEF/ST103SeahawksSEADEF/ST
104Mike WilliamsTBWR104BearsCHIDEF/ST
105Ben RoethlisbergerPITQB105Sidney RiceSEAWR
106Justin BlackmonJACWR106TexansHOUDEF/ST
107Ben TateHOURB107BroncosDENDEF/ST
108Andy DaltonCINQB108BengalsCINDEF/ST
109Brian HartlineMIAWR109Giovani BernardCINRB
110Michael BushCHIRB110PatriotsNEDEF/ST
111TexansHOUDEF/ST111Isaiah PeadSTLRB
112Brandon MyersNYGTE112CardinalsARIDEF/ST
113Shane VereenNERB113Matt BryantATLK
114Stephen GostkowskiNEK114Sebastian JanikowskiOAKK
115Isaiah PeadSTLRB115Phil DawsonSFK
11649ersSFDEF/ST116Kenny BrittTENWR
117Josh GordonCLEWR117Blair WalshMINK
118Jermichael FinleyGBTE118Matt PraterDENK
119Bryce BrownPHIRB119Justin TuckerBALK
120Mikel LeshoureDETRB120Lawrence TynesNYGK
121Denarius MooreOAKWR121Josh BrownNYGK
122Jacquizz RodgersATLRB122David AkersDETK
123Aaron DobsonNEWR123Andre BrownNYGRB
124Robert TurbinSEARB124Jason HansonRETIREDK
125Owen DanielsHOUTE125RavensBALDEF/ST
126Bernard PierceBALRB126Carson PalmerARIQB
127Darrius Heyward-BeyINDWR127RamsSTLDEF/ST
128BroncosDENDEF/ST128Emmanuel SandersPITWR
129Mike GoodsonNYJRB129Jonathan StewartCARRB
130Alshon JefferyCHIWR130DeAndre HopkinsHOUWR
131Greg OlsenCARTE131Mark IngramNORB
132Michael VickPHIQB132Mikel LeshoureDETRB
133BearsCHIDEF/ST133PackersGBDEF/ST
134Vincent BrownSDWR134Bryce BrownPHIRB
135Emmanuel SandersPITWR135DeAngelo WililamsCARRB
136DeAngelo WililamsCARRB136Shane VereenNERB
137Philip RiversSDQB137Jared CookSTLTE
138Denard RobinsonJACRB138Johnathan FranklinGBRB
139Joe FlaccoBALQB139Denarius MooreOAKWR
140Sidney RiceSEAWR140Fred JacksonBUFRB
141BuccaneersTBDEF/ST141Joe FlaccoBALQB
142Brandon PettigrewDETTE142Brian HartlineMIAWR
143Joseph RandleDALRB143Philip RiversSDQB
144BengalsCINDEF/ST144Alshon JefferyCHIWR
145PatriotsNEDEF/ST145Andy DaltonCINQB
146Cordarrelle PattersonMINWR146Kendall WrightTENWR
147Blair WalshMINK147Brandon MyersNYGTE
148Michael FloydARIWR148Bernard PierceBALRB
149Santonio HolmesNYJWR149Jermichael FinleyGBTE
150Kendall WrightTENWR150Malcom FloydSDWR
151Michael CrabtreeSFWR151Brandon PettigrewDETTE
152Ryan WilliamsARIRB152Chris GivensSTLWR
153Chris GivensSTLWR153Mohamed SanuCHIWR
154Jay CutlerCHIQB154Connor BarthTBK
155Danny WoodheadSDRB155Jermaine GreshamCINTE
156Sam BradfordSTLQB156Matt SchaubHOUQB
157Martellus BennettCHITE157Jay CutlerCHIQB
158RavensBALDEF/ST158Zac StacySTLRB
159Matt SchaubHOUQB159Santonio HolmesNYJWR
160Ronnie HillmanDENRB160Josh FreemanTBQB
161Jacoby JonesBALWR161Michael FloydARIWR
162Mohamed SanuCHIWR162Sam BradfordSTLQB
163SteelersPITDEF/ST163Vincent BrownSDWR
164Carson PalmerARIQB164Brandon LloydFAWR
165Brandon LaFellCARWR165Jacquizz RodgersATLRB
166LaMichael JamesSFRB166Darrius Heyward-BeyINDWR
167Willis McGaheeDENRB167A.J. JenkinsSFWR
168Marcel ReeceOAKRB168Fred DavisWASTE
169Josh FreemanTBQB169Golden TateSEAWR
170Mike GillisleeMIARB170SteelersPITDEF/ST
171Shonn GreeneTENRB171Brandon LaFellCARWR
172Brian QuickSTLWR172Alex SmithKCQB
173A.J. JenkinsSFWR173Aaron DobsonNEWR
174Rueben RandleNYGWR174Ryan TannehillMIAQB
175CardinalsARIDEF/ST175Andre RobertsARIWR
176Ryan TannehillMIAQB176Heath MillerPITTE
177Dan BaileyDALK177Rueben RandleNYGWR
178Pierre ThomasNORB178Rob HouslerARITE
179Phil DawsonSFK179Ben TateHOURB
180Daniel ThomasMIARB180Greg LittleCLEWR
181Matt BryantATLK181LaMichael JamesSFRB
182Heath MillerPITTE182Cordarrelle PattersonMINWR
183Matt PraterDENK183Joseph MorganNOWR
184Tyler EifertCINTE184Dan BaileyDALK
185RamsSTLDEF/ST185Jordan CameronCLETE
186Jonathan DwyerPITRB186GiantsNYGDEF/ST
187Justin TuckerBALK187Jake LockerTENQB
188BrownsCLEDEF/ST188Robert WoodsBUFWR
189Ryan BroylesDETWR189Rod StreaterOAKWR
190LeGarrette BlountNERB190Ryan BroylesDETWR
191Greg ZuerleinSTLK191Dwayne AllenINDTE
192Sebastian JanikowskiOAKK192Delanie WalkerTENTE
193Randy BullockHOUK193BuccaneersTBDEF/ST
194Lawrence TynesNYGK194Dustin KellerMIATE
195Mario ManninghamSFWR195Peyton HillisKCRB
196Garrett HartleyNOK196Joseph RandleDALRB
197Malcom FloydSDWR197Ryan WilliamsARIRB
198EJ ManuelBUFQB198Danny WoodheadSDRB
199PackersGBDEF/ST199Jacoby JonesBALWR
200Justin ForsettJACRB200Michael BushCHIRB
201Knowshon MorenoDENRB201Mike GoodsonNYJRB
202Tim TebowNEQB202Pierre ThomasNORB
203Knile DavisKCRB203Tyler EifertCINTE
204Latavius MurrayOAKRB204BrownsCLEDEF/ST
205Robbie GouldCHIK205Randy BullockHOUK
206Keenan AllenSDWR206Garrett HartleyNOK
207Alex SmithKCQB207Justin ForsettJACRB
208Mason CrosbyGBK208Latavius MurrayOAKRB
209Robert WoodsBUFWR209Mario ManninghamSFWR
210GiantsNYGDEF/ST210Santana MossWASWR
Enhanced by Zemanta