Comparing deep league mock drafts – 14 team draft results and ranks from fantasy football calculator and yahoo

14

14 (Photo credit: xiaming)

Thought it would be fun to do a side by side comparison of two deep league mock drafts that I recently completed.  On the left side we have the results from fantasy football calculator (popular mock draft site) and on the right are the results from Yahoo.  Both mock drafts were completed for the same position requirements – 1 QB, 2 RB, 3 WR, TE, DEF, K, and 6 bench spots for a total of 15 players.

If you are an avid fantasy football player, chances are the rankings seem pretty set in stone to you (especially for the first 2-3 rounds) but as you will see with this comparison, the rankings are drastically different depending on the site that you are using.  Both mocks were completed on June 11th, with all 14 fantasy owners in attendance, and they can’t even agree on the basic order for the first round!

The one trend that you will notice, as expected, is that the running backs went early and often

Deep league mock draft comparison – 14 teams

FantasyFootballCalculator.com                                                             Yahoo.com

Rank Player Team POS Rank Player Team POS
1 Arian Foster HOU RB 1 Adrian Peterson MIN RB
2 Adrian Peterson MIN RB 2 Arian Foster HOU RB
3 Marshawn Lynch SEA RB 3 Doug Martin TB RB
4 Jamaal Charles KC RB 4 LeSean McCoy PHI RB
5 Doug Martin TB RB 5 C.J. Spiller BUF RB
6 Calvin Johnson DET WR 6 Jamaal Charles KC RB
7 C.J. Spiller BUF RB 7 Calvin Johnson DET WR
8 Ray Rice BAL RB 8 Ray Rice BAL RB
9 LeSean McCoy PHI RB 9 Marshawn Lynch SEA RB
10 Alfred Morris WAS RB 10 Trent Richardson CLE RB
11 Trent Richardson CLE RB 11 Alfred Morris WAS RB
12 Dez Bryant DAL WR 12 Maurice Jones-Drew JAC RB
13 Matt Forte CHI RB 13 Steven Jackson ATL RB
14 A.J. Green CIN WR 14 Dez Bryant DAL WR
15 Steven Jackson ATL RB 15 Darren Sproles NO RB
16 Chris Johnson TEN RB 16 Drew Brees NO QB
17 Maurice Jones-Drew JAC RB 17 A.J. Green CIN WR
18 Stevan Ridley NE RB 18 Matt Forte CHI RB
19 Frank Gore SF RB 19 Brandon Marshall CHI WR
20 David Wilson NYG RB 20 Julio Jones ATL WR
21 Brandon Marshall CHI WR 21 Peyton Manning DEN QB
22 DeMarco Murray DAL RB 22 Aaron Rodgers GB QB
23 Julio Jones ATL WR 23 Jimmy Graham NO TE
24 Demaryius Thomas DEN WR 24 Larry Fitzgerald ARI WR
25 Darren McFadden OAK RB 25 Chris Johnson TEN RB
26 Jimmy Graham NO TE 26 Demaryius Thomas DEN WR
27 Aaron Rodgers GB QB 27 Stevan Ridley NE RB
28 Reggie Bush DET RB 28 Cam Newton CAR QB
29 Drew Brees NO QB 29 Victor Cruz NYG WR
30 Percy Harvin SEA WR 30 Randall Cobb GB WR
31 Roddy White ATL WR 31 Roddy White ATL WR
32 Montee Ball DEN RB 32 Percy Harvin SEA WR
33 Larry Fitzgerald ARI WR 33 Tom Brady NE QB
34 Darren Sproles NO RB 34 Andre Johnson HOU WR
35 Randall Cobb GB WR 35 Frank Gore SF RB
36 Andre Johnson HOU WR 36 Matt Ryan ATL QB
37 Lamar Miller MIA RB 37 Vincent Jackson TB WR
38 Le’Veon Bell PIT RB 38 Darren McFadden OAK RB
39 Peyton Manning DEN QB 39 Marques Colston NO WR
40 Chris Ivory NYJ RB 40 Matthew Stafford DET QB
41 Marques Colston NO WR 41 Lamar Miller MIA RB
42 Tom Brady NE QB 42 Reggie Wayne IND WR
43 Ryan Mathews SD RB 43 DeMarco Murray DAL RB
44 Dwayne Bowe KC WR 44 Antonio Brown PIT WR
45 Cam Newton CAR QB 45 Reggie Bush DET RB
46 Vincent Jackson TB WR 46 Jordy Nelson GB WR
47 Danny Amendola NE WR 47 Russell Wilson SEA QB
48 Jason Witten DAL TE 48 Le’Veon Bell PIT RB
49 Jordy Nelson GB WR 49 Wes Welker DEN WR
50 Colin Kaepernick SF QB 50 David Wilson NYG RB
51 Victor Cruz NYG WR 51 Colin Kaepernick SF QB
52 Reggie Wayne IND WR 52 Dwayne Bowe KC WR
53 Rob Gronkowski NE TE 53 Ryan Mathews SD RB
54 BenJarvus Green-Ellis CIN RB 54 Hakeem Nicks NYG WR
55 Wes Welker DEN WR 55 Danny Amendola NE WR
56 Hakeem Nicks NYG WR 56 Aaron Hernandez NE TE
57 Mike Wallace MIA WR 57 Torrey Smith BAL WR
58 Aaron Hernandez NE TE 58 Eric Decker DEN WR
59 Vernon Davis SF TE 59 Montee Ball DEN RB
60 Matt Ryan ATL QB 60 Mike Wallace MIA WR
61 Eddie Lacy GB RB 61 Rob Gronkowski NE TE
62 Vick Ballard IND RB 62 Steve Smith CAR WR
63 Torrey Smith BAL WR 63 James Jones GB WR
64 Rashard Mendenhall ARI RB 64 Anquan Boldin SF WR
65 Matthew Stafford DET QB 65 Robert Griffin III WAS QB
66 Tavon Austin STL WR 66 Tony Gonzalez ATL TE
67 Antonio Brown PIT WR 67 Andrew Luck IND QB
68 Pierre Garcon WAS WR 68 Pierre Garcon WAS WR
69 Robert Griffin III WAS QB 69 Lance Moore NO WR
70 Tony Gonzalez ATL TE 70 Steve Johnson BUF WR
71 Danario Alexander SD WR 71 Jason Witten DAL TE
72 Eric Decker DEN WR 72 Justin Blackmon JAC WR
73 Steve Smith CAR WR 73 49ers SF DEF/ST
74 Mark Ingram NO RB 74 Danario Alexander SD WR
75 Russell Wilson SEA QB 75 DeSean Jackson PHI WR
76 Greg Jennings MIN WR 76 Dennis Pitta BAL TE
77 Giovani Bernard CIN RB 77 Vernon Davis SF TE
78 Andrew Luck IND QB 78 Greg Jennings MIN WR
79 Tony Romo DAL QB 79 Jeremy Maclin PHI WR
80 Andre Brown NYG RB 80 Vick Ballard IND RB
81 James Jones GB WR 81 Tony Romo DAL QB
82 Cecil Shorts JAC WR 82 Kyle Rudolph MIN TE
83 Fred Jackson BUF RB 83 Eli Manning NYG QB
84 Daryl Richardson STL RB 84 Chris Ivory NYJ RB
85 Miles Austin DAL WR 85 Cecil Shorts JAC WR
86 Anquan Boldin SF WR 86 Owen Daniels HOU TE
87 Eli Manning NYG QB 87 Ben Roethlisberger PIT QB
88 T.Y. Hilton IND WR 88 Josh Gordon CLE WR
89 Antonio Gates SD TE 89 Miles Austin DAL WR
90 Johnathan Franklin GB RB 90 Rashard Mendenhall ARI RB
91 Kyle Rudolph MIN TE 91 Greg Olsen CAR TE
92 Dennis Pitta BAL TE 92 BenJarvus Green-Ellis CIN RB
93 Steve Johnson BUF WR 93 T.Y. Hilton IND WR
94 Lance Moore NO WR 94 Tavon Austin STL WR
95 Jeremy Maclin PHI WR 95 Eddie Lacy GB RB
96 Kenny Britt TEN WR 96 Mike Williams TB WR
97 Zac Stacy STL RB 97 Martellus Bennett CHI TE
98 Ahmad Bradshaw IND RB 98 Michael Vick PHI QB
99 DeAndre Hopkins HOU WR 99 Daryl Richardson STL RB
100 Jonathan Stewart CAR RB 100 Stephen Gostkowski NE K
101 DeSean Jackson PHI WR 101 Antonio Gates SD TE
102 Jared Cook STL TE 102 Ahmad Bradshaw IND RB
103 Seahawks SEA DEF/ST 103 Seahawks SEA DEF/ST
104 Mike Williams TB WR 104 Bears CHI DEF/ST
105 Ben Roethlisberger PIT QB 105 Sidney Rice SEA WR
106 Justin Blackmon JAC WR 106 Texans HOU DEF/ST
107 Ben Tate HOU RB 107 Broncos DEN DEF/ST
108 Andy Dalton CIN QB 108 Bengals CIN DEF/ST
109 Brian Hartline MIA WR 109 Giovani Bernard CIN RB
110 Michael Bush CHI RB 110 Patriots NE DEF/ST
111 Texans HOU DEF/ST 111 Isaiah Pead STL RB
112 Brandon Myers NYG TE 112 Cardinals ARI DEF/ST
113 Shane Vereen NE RB 113 Matt Bryant ATL K
114 Stephen Gostkowski NE K 114 Sebastian Janikowski OAK K
115 Isaiah Pead STL RB 115 Phil Dawson SF K
116 49ers SF DEF/ST 116 Kenny Britt TEN WR
117 Josh Gordon CLE WR 117 Blair Walsh MIN K
118 Jermichael Finley GB TE 118 Matt Prater DEN K
119 Bryce Brown PHI RB 119 Justin Tucker BAL K
120 Mikel Leshoure DET RB 120 Lawrence Tynes NYG K
121 Denarius Moore OAK WR 121 Josh Brown NYG K
122 Jacquizz Rodgers ATL RB 122 David Akers DET K
123 Aaron Dobson NE WR 123 Andre Brown NYG RB
124 Robert Turbin SEA RB 124 Jason Hanson RETIRED K
125 Owen Daniels HOU TE 125 Ravens BAL DEF/ST
126 Bernard Pierce BAL RB 126 Carson Palmer ARI QB
127 Darrius Heyward-Bey IND WR 127 Rams STL DEF/ST
128 Broncos DEN DEF/ST 128 Emmanuel Sanders PIT WR
129 Mike Goodson NYJ RB 129 Jonathan Stewart CAR RB
130 Alshon Jeffery CHI WR 130 DeAndre Hopkins HOU WR
131 Greg Olsen CAR TE 131 Mark Ingram NO RB
132 Michael Vick PHI QB 132 Mikel Leshoure DET RB
133 Bears CHI DEF/ST 133 Packers GB DEF/ST
134 Vincent Brown SD WR 134 Bryce Brown PHI RB
135 Emmanuel Sanders PIT WR 135 DeAngelo Wililams CAR RB
136 DeAngelo Wililams CAR RB 136 Shane Vereen NE RB
137 Philip Rivers SD QB 137 Jared Cook STL TE
138 Denard Robinson JAC RB 138 Johnathan Franklin GB RB
139 Joe Flacco BAL QB 139 Denarius Moore OAK WR
140 Sidney Rice SEA WR 140 Fred Jackson BUF RB
141 Buccaneers TB DEF/ST 141 Joe Flacco BAL QB
142 Brandon Pettigrew DET TE 142 Brian Hartline MIA WR
143 Joseph Randle DAL RB 143 Philip Rivers SD QB
144 Bengals CIN DEF/ST 144 Alshon Jeffery CHI WR
145 Patriots NE DEF/ST 145 Andy Dalton CIN QB
146 Cordarrelle Patterson MIN WR 146 Kendall Wright TEN WR
147 Blair Walsh MIN K 147 Brandon Myers NYG TE
148 Michael Floyd ARI WR 148 Bernard Pierce BAL RB
149 Santonio Holmes NYJ WR 149 Jermichael Finley GB TE
150 Kendall Wright TEN WR 150 Malcom Floyd SD WR
151 Michael Crabtree SF WR 151 Brandon Pettigrew DET TE
152 Ryan Williams ARI RB 152 Chris Givens STL WR
153 Chris Givens STL WR 153 Mohamed Sanu CHI WR
154 Jay Cutler CHI QB 154 Connor Barth TB K
155 Danny Woodhead SD RB 155 Jermaine Gresham CIN TE
156 Sam Bradford STL QB 156 Matt Schaub HOU QB
157 Martellus Bennett CHI TE 157 Jay Cutler CHI QB
158 Ravens BAL DEF/ST 158 Zac Stacy STL RB
159 Matt Schaub HOU QB 159 Santonio Holmes NYJ WR
160 Ronnie Hillman DEN RB 160 Josh Freeman TB QB
161 Jacoby Jones BAL WR 161 Michael Floyd ARI WR
162 Mohamed Sanu CHI WR 162 Sam Bradford STL QB
163 Steelers PIT DEF/ST 163 Vincent Brown SD WR
164 Carson Palmer ARI QB 164 Brandon Lloyd FA WR
165 Brandon LaFell CAR WR 165 Jacquizz Rodgers ATL RB
166 LaMichael James SF RB 166 Darrius Heyward-Bey IND WR
167 Willis McGahee DEN RB 167 A.J. Jenkins SF WR
168 Marcel Reece OAK RB 168 Fred Davis WAS TE
169 Josh Freeman TB QB 169 Golden Tate SEA WR
170 Mike Gillislee MIA RB 170 Steelers PIT DEF/ST
171 Shonn Greene TEN RB 171 Brandon LaFell CAR WR
172 Brian Quick STL WR 172 Alex Smith KC QB
173 A.J. Jenkins SF WR 173 Aaron Dobson NE WR
174 Rueben Randle NYG WR 174 Ryan Tannehill MIA QB
175 Cardinals ARI DEF/ST 175 Andre Roberts ARI WR
176 Ryan Tannehill MIA QB 176 Heath Miller PIT TE
177 Dan Bailey DAL K 177 Rueben Randle NYG WR
178 Pierre Thomas NO RB 178 Rob Housler ARI TE
179 Phil Dawson SF K 179 Ben Tate HOU RB
180 Daniel Thomas MIA RB 180 Greg Little CLE WR
181 Matt Bryant ATL K 181 LaMichael James SF RB
182 Heath Miller PIT TE 182 Cordarrelle Patterson MIN WR
183 Matt Prater DEN K 183 Joseph Morgan NO WR
184 Tyler Eifert CIN TE 184 Dan Bailey DAL K
185 Rams STL DEF/ST 185 Jordan Cameron CLE TE
186 Jonathan Dwyer PIT RB 186 Giants NYG DEF/ST
187 Justin Tucker BAL K 187 Jake Locker TEN QB
188 Browns CLE DEF/ST 188 Robert Woods BUF WR
189 Ryan Broyles DET WR 189 Rod Streater OAK WR
190 LeGarrette Blount NE RB 190 Ryan Broyles DET WR
191 Greg Zuerlein STL K 191 Dwayne Allen IND TE
192 Sebastian Janikowski OAK K 192 Delanie Walker TEN TE
193 Randy Bullock HOU K 193 Buccaneers TB DEF/ST
194 Lawrence Tynes NYG K 194 Dustin Keller MIA TE
195 Mario Manningham SF WR 195 Peyton Hillis KC RB
196 Garrett Hartley NO K 196 Joseph Randle DAL RB
197 Malcom Floyd SD WR 197 Ryan Williams ARI RB
198 EJ Manuel BUF QB 198 Danny Woodhead SD RB
199 Packers GB DEF/ST 199 Jacoby Jones BAL WR
200 Justin Forsett JAC RB 200 Michael Bush CHI RB
201 Knowshon Moreno DEN RB 201 Mike Goodson NYJ RB
202 Tim Tebow NE QB 202 Pierre Thomas NO RB
203 Knile Davis KC RB 203 Tyler Eifert CIN TE
204 Latavius Murray OAK RB 204 Browns CLE DEF/ST
205 Robbie Gould CHI K 205 Randy Bullock HOU K
206 Keenan Allen SD WR 206 Garrett Hartley NO K
207 Alex Smith KC QB 207 Justin Forsett JAC RB
208 Mason Crosby GB K 208 Latavius Murray OAK RB
209 Robert Woods BUF WR 209 Mario Manningham SF WR
210 Giants NYG DEF/ST 210 Santana Moss WAS WR
Enhanced by Zemanta
The following two tabs change content below.

K J

Lead Writer / Editor at FantasyTeamAdvice
Lead Writer and Editor of FantasyTeamAdvice.com. Our website allows fantasy sports fans and writers the opportunity to dish out their own unique brand of fantasy advice to over 4 Million viewers per year (and still growing!). You can find me in the forums on a regular basis interacting with one of the fastest growing fantasy sports communities on the web today.